First off, please excuse this review that was written in a New York minute. I’m off to Paris tomorrow and swamped with things to do. Okay, the message in the blurb was what attracted me to this novel. The story was about a brave and loving family that usually was in a hectic state from the responsibilities of raising five sons. Besides all the challenges that come with a large family, they were also struggling with the difficulties of bringing up a transgender child. The parents immediately noticed that their youngest son was different. He was sweeter, calmer and more sensitive than his older brothers ever were. He didn’t like to wrestle with them or blow things up, he would rather spend his time in a Cinderella coloring book. At the age of three, he started to ask his parents if he could wear a dress. They didn’t see any red flags because they thought, Don’t most children of both sexes want to wear their mom’s heels sometime in their early childhood? By the time he was five, they let him wear a dress at home but not to kindergarten, but it was so clear that this little boy did not want to be a boy.
My heart broke for this child when he asked his parents, if when he grew up, would he finally be a girl. He was so miserable being a boy that both parents knew something needed to be done. With the help of the school’s social worker, his parents let him wear a dress, hair barrettes and all sorts of “girly” accessories to school. This was too confusing to all at the school and the poor kid had to use the nurse’s bathroom. The family decided to move from Wisconsin to Seattle, which is a more gay-friendly state. However, even in Seattle (where their little boy is now passing as a little girl) they still kept their secret, because they simply didn’t know how to explain the situation. Nevertheless their unhappy five-year-old son starts school as a very happy little girl.
In the end-notes, we learn that the author has a transgender daughter, but she makes it clear that this is not her story. She does a wonderful job of raising awareness on gender dysphoria. But for me, the story read unrealistically. All the complications that would arise in such a family were too easily solved. All of her brothers were 100% supportive without any questions asked. At the age of ten, this child was “outed.” Of course the transgirl was devastated. So the mother, who is a doctor, takes her youngest child to Thailand on an excursion to work at a clinic there. Here the child is exposed to Buddah and discovers that Buddah could be a man or a woman. In Thailand, she meets many people who are genderless. The country is very accepting of all gender identities and she gets a big boost of encouragement and decides that it was time to go home and try school again. This is wonderful for the character, but let’s be realistic. Most moms wouldn’t be able to just pick up and go to a foreign country. Plus, the ending was so tidy, it should have been wrapped up in a bow. Back in the States, at her school (where now all know what is under her pants), she is completely accepted. At her first dance, she is asked to dance by a boy she has a crush on. It is doubtful to me that such acceptance would come so easily to children. How I wish this was true, and maybe one day soon, it will be. But in the year of 2017 it was hard to buy. I hope I’m wrong about this.
This was a sweet story about a loving and wonderful family who would move mountains if that was what it took to raise a happy child. The story was more about how to be a loving parent to a transgender child, so I guess the book needed to be written. But, I found that the tale often went flat. (I actually started to skip the father’s fairytales created to help his daughter cope). For me, I much preferred the novels “Trans-Sister Radio” by Chris Bohjalian and “Middlesex” by Jeffrey Eugenides that were also on the subject of being transgender.
Find all my reviews at https://www.goodreads.com/review/list/4793025-martie-nees-record?shelf=read